Wind Power Report Shows Facts Instead of Myths

Despite rapid growth in this renewable energy resource, ABS Energy Research's latest report highlights new evidence from operators, which shows that the benefits claimed for wind power are not always what they seem.




The Report shows continued growth in wind power generating capacity. Capacity in this type of renewable energy increased by 11.3 GW in 2005 to reach a total of 59 GW. Germany is the world leader, with 31 percent of the world's installed capacity, followed by Spain, the USA, India and Denmark.

The big surprise among the five leaders was the recovery and surge in production in the USA after years of stagnation. Guaranteed production tax credits, valid for a three year period instead of annually as before have justified the new investment in renewable energy.

Growth is expected to continue. As the leaders consolidate and re-power smaller installations with larger turbines, the market is now widening and entering a new phase with many new countries entering the market for renewable energy resources, such as wind.

The most important findings of this report highlight studies that raise critical concerns challenging some of the claims made for wind power. Badly needed evidence is now available after three years of large scale operation of wind turbines in five countries. In one such country, Ireland, the government placed a moratorium on wind power development, although this has been rescinded.

These studies are the first real evidence showing how wind actually works, as opposed to what has been claimed, and come from some of the most authoritative voices on energy in the world. Reports from E.On Netz, the system operator with the largest wind power feed-in in the world, and Eltra of Denmark, which had the largest percentage wind power contribution, show disturbing results.

E.On cites a study from the Deutsche-Energie Agentur. The report was sponsored by the German government and all sides of the industry. Among bombshells contained inside, the study suggests that while wind power capacity will reach 48 GW by 2020 in Germany, the source is so intermittent and unreliable that it is equivalent to only 2 GW of stable fossil fuel capacity.

The evidence also shows a mismatch of supply and demand. High pressure weather systems bring cold winters and hot summers which unfortunately coincide with low wind levels. These meteorological realities mean that wind makes its maximum contribution when demand is lowest and its minimum contribution when demand is highest. In 2004, wind accounted for 20 percent of total electricity production in Denmark but supplied only 6 percent of consumption, because it produced a surplus at periods of lowest demand. What's more, 84 percent of Danish wind-generated electricity was exported to Norway, and sold at a loss for Denmark. Furthermore, the Norwegian electricity system uses carbon free hydro power, so the effect of carbon reductions realised in power produced by windmills was nullified.

Also, because of this variability in wind, back-up fossil fuel plants must be operated at low load to maintain system reliability. There is new evidence that shows that switching base load fossil fuel plants on and off to balance a system produces higher carbon emissions than continuous operation, certainly not a supposed benefit from switching to renewable energy sources.

Because wind installations tend to be concentrated in areas with high wind speeds, regional grids are heavily overloaded at times of maximum feed-in. Each country studied reported extreme difficulties in balancing the grid. A further 2,700 km of costly high voltage transmission lines will be required in Germany to accommodate new wind capacity.

It is clear that wind-generated electricity can only work as part of a generation portfolio. The US Department of Energy advocates small local targets within states, most recently proposing targets of 100 MW in each of the 30 states, rather than the huge wind parks favoured in Europe.

ABS Energy Research's report does not relegate wind power to the dustbin. But it does show how essential proper analysis is to establish what renewable energy can and cannot deliver and how it must be accommodated within a total electricity generation system. Objective analysis is essential. Nearly every one of the points described in the study has been labelled a "myth" by a lobby group.

About ABS Energy Research
ABS Energy Research's (www.absenergyresearch.com) extensive report was compiled through a comprehensive literature search, the help of the regulators and assistance from governments, energy organisations and metrological bureaux.

For more information, please contact Melany Krangle at:
ABS Energy Research
8 Quarry Road
London SW18 2QJ
UK

Tel: +44 (0) 20 8432 6378

WIND WATCH 27 OCTOBER

New ZealandNews
27 Oct 2006

Monitoring tower installed

Alexandra: The Australian company planning a wind farm in the Cairnmuir Mountains recently installed another monitoring tower near Gimmerburn. Roaring 40s formerly known as Hydro Tasmania confirmed it was in the early stages of assessing the Rough Ridge site in the Maniototo and had recently installed a wind tower. Project development manager Richard Mackie said he was ... Complete story »

---

NewsMontana
27 Oct 2006

Wind project proposed east of Livingston

LIVINGSTON - A Minnesota company is proposing to erect about 25 big wind turbines somewhere between here and Springdale. The project is still in its early phases, but Outland Renewable Energy is negotiating with landowners and potential investors here, according to Pat Pelstring of Wind Energy Developers, which is working for Outland. In its initial stages, the ... Complete story »

---

WisconsinNews
27 Oct 2006

Citizen questions school energy study during recent Clintonville board meeting

Not everyone agrees the proposal Mark Lentz of Lentz Engineering Associates has made to the Board of Education should be approved. Ben Huber regular addressed the board Monday with recommendations and concerns on the proposal that could cost the district between million and 16 million for HVAC system upgrades and a wind turbine. Earlier this year ... Complete story »

---

New ZealandNews
27 Oct 2006

Motorimu Wind Farm Proposal

Palmerston North City Council and Horowhenua District Council have received land use consent applications from Motorimu Wind Farm Limited to construct, operate and maintain 129 wind turbines as part of a proposal known as the 'Motorimu Wind Farm'. Both Councils consider that because of the potential for the proposal to generate more than minor ... Complete story »

---

AustraliaNews
27 Oct 2006

Victoria approves huge windfarm project

ELEANOR HALL: In Victoria, The Bracks Government has approved plans for the largest wind farm project in the Southern Hemisphere. The Macarthur wind farm in southwestern Victoria will provide power for up to 190,000 homes each year. And planning Minister Rob Hulls says it's proof of the Bracks Government's commitment to tackling climate change. But opponents of the ... Complete story »

---

New ZealandNews
27 Oct 2006

PNCC gets wind farm applications

Palmerston North City Council and Horowhenua District Council have received resource consent applications from Motorimu Wind Farm Limited for a 129-turbine wind farm on part of the Tararua Ranges near Linton and Tokomaru. The applications have been publicly notified and the closing date for submissions is 4pm on November 24. stuff.co.nz ... Complete story »

---

NewsBritish Columbia
27 Oct 2006

Tower to test site for wind farm

Soon the Fly Hills will be adorned with a 150-foot-tall pole that might lead to a new source of power for B.C. Natural Power Consultants Ltd., a Scotland-based company which set up shop in Canada about a year ago, will be putting up a metal meteorological tower in the Fly Hills west of town in the ... Complete story »

---

U.K.News
27 Oct 2006

Wind farm plan for Oughterside

Residents near a West Cumbrian village will be asked their views on plans for a £15 million six-turbine wind farm. Norwich company Mellinsus Renewables has agreement from three Oughterside landowners for its development. It will hold open days at Prospect Village Hall on Friday and Saturday next week to tell residents about the six wind turbines, renewable ... Complete story »

---

U.K.NewsOffshore
27 Oct 2006

Robin Rigg windfarm work starts

An unusual vessel is working off the West Cumbrian coast to prepare for the installation of the 60-turbine Robin Rigg wind farm. The MV Resolution is the world's first purpose-built vessel for installing offshore wind turbines and has been carrying out investigations of the site in the Solway Firth where energy firm E.On UK Renewables plans ... Complete story »

---

U.K.News
27 Oct 2006

Two 'blots on the landscape'

A second application to build a huge wind farm at West Hinkley has been submitted by Your Energy - sparking further fear amongst campaigners. Nine turbines have now been proposed for the site on the West Somerset coastline which planners protected last year by throwing out the plans. But while the Government's Planning Inspectorate could yet overturn ... Complete story »

---

U.K.News
27 Oct 2006

D-Day looms for wind farm scheme

The comprehensive landscape reasons for planners recommending the IW Council turn down the controversial Wellow wind farm have been unveiled to the public, ahead of Monday's planning decision on the scheme. Consultants acting for the IW Council concluded the six turbines, two of which are nearly 110 metres tall, would have significant adverse effects on the ... Complete story »

---

U.K.News
27 Oct 2006

We'll take windfarm fight right to the top

Furious protestors opposed to a windfarm in Auchtermuchty have vowed to fight tooth and nail against the proposal. As revealed in last week's Fife Herald, developer EnergieKontor will soon have the option to by-pass Fife Council and force a decision on its controversial application from the Scottish Executive. But campaign group Auchtermuchty Landscape and Environment said it ... Complete story »

---

Where Are the Defenders of Nature and Communities?

National Wind Watch challenges support of industrial wind power by major non-profit groups

[Press Release]

Rowe, Mass., October 26, 2006 -- Many advocacy groups, fighting global warming and the negative environmental and health impacts of fossil fuel or nuclear energy, have embraced large-scale wind power as part of a solution.

Those organizations are misguided in their support of wind energy, says National Wind Watch (NWW), a coalition of grass-root groups defending wild places and rural communities from industrial development.

"Groups like Greenpeace and the state PIRGs [Public Interest Research Groups] have built their reputations by speaking out against rampant development and destruction of the environment," says Eric Rosenbloom, a Vermont science writer and current president of NWW. "In the past, they have reliably taken the side of communities against the greed of heedless corporations or convenient politics. But with industrial wind, they've gone to the other side. They're effectively acting as shills for giant energy companies looking for a fast buck with a trendy but very flawed technology that destroys landscapes, ecosystems, and communities."

According to material on NWW's web site, www.wind-watch.org, wind power on the grid has not been shown to reduce emissions or replace other sources of electricity to any degree that justifies its own negative impacts. Because it responds only to the fluctuating wind and not to actual user demand, it adds instability to the power load, thus further burdening other sources of power to keep the system balanced.

Since the environmental benefits aren't there, NWW questions the support of industrial wind power by so many organizations that are otherwise defenders of the environment.

"The argument that local sacrifices are necessary to save the planet just doesn't hold up," said Lloyd Crawford, NWW treasurer and owner of Stump Sprouts guest lodge and cross-country ski center in West Hawley, Mass. "These giant machines won't make the slightest dent in global warming. Their negative impacts, on the other hand, are substantial."

Those impacts include the disruption and deaths of birds and bats, fragmentation of habitat, damage to watersheds, and visual as well as auditory intrusion day and night. In addition to their immense height, tons of cement and steel in the foundations, and acres of clearance, wind power facilities require strong straight roads and substantial new transmission infrastructure.

National Wind Watch calls on all organizations interested in protecting the environment, wildlife, and our communities to more carefully consider the facts about industrial wind energy. The unavoidable conclusion is that big wind is a threat rather than a savior to those interests.

The statement from National Wind Watch was released to coincide with the 16th annual conference of the Society of Environmental Journalists in Burlington, Vt., Oct. 25Ð29, 2006. NWW will be represented at an exhibit table by its Vermont affiliates led by Sheffield-based Ridge Protectors, along with Kansas affiliate Protect the Flint Hills and Industrial Wind Action of New Hampshire.

This is the second year that NWW has exhibited at the SEJ conference. The ad hoc Coalition for Responsible Wind Power, created by Sierra Club of Maryland Conservation Chair and NWW founding member Dan Boone, has exhibited for the previous two years and last year welcomed the newly formed National Wind Watch to participate.

National Wind Watch information and contacts are available at www.wind-watch.org.

---

National Wind Watch is a nonprofit corporation that promotes knowledge and raises awareness of the negative environmental and social impacts of industrial wind energy development. Information, analysis, and other materials are available on its web site, www.wind-watch.org.

MERIDIAN'S PROJECT HAYES (sticky)

MERIDIAN'S PROJECT HAYES

A PDF of the Central Otago District Council submission form for the
Meridian scheme is now available from our website:
www.uplandlandscapeprotection.org. [When you get there, click on "Downloads" on the navigation bar]. It must be printed out and sent by
post to the advertised address. The due date is 24 November.

We will shortly be sending out our overview of the central issues at
stake by post, alongside submission forms. We cannot emphasise enough
the importance of the community taking part in this forthcoming
hearing; we strongly encourage you to express your concerns about
Meridian's development, whatever they are. You will not have the chance
again.

News Watch

[ a service of National Wind Watch, Inc. ]

---

JapanNews
23 Oct 2006

Tokyo Report: Wind power projects face foul wind

An unfavorable wind is starting to blow against wind power generation in Japan. Wind power is often referred to as an environment-friendly energy source that emits no carbon dioxide. Consequently generators are being built in many parts of Japan. However, a small but growing number of people, especially intellectuals, are voicing opposition to the construction of wind ... Complete story »

---

U.K.News
23 Oct 2006

Biggest wind power project is blown off course as residents fight back

Martin Bellis dries himself off with his towel and gives a wry smile when asked if he is not just another Nimby objector looking after his own patch of beach against the potential encroachment of a wind farm near Faversham, Kent. "No, I'm really not. I am a supporter of clean energy and really care ... Complete story »

---

MassachusettsNews
23 Oct 2006

Bay State 'behind on wind power'

Massachusetts is joining a race against other U.S. states for wind power development funding to build infrastructure necessary to keep innovation here, and reverse a track record of letting wind technologies drift out to the Midwest. In addition to playing catch-up, Massachusetts officials face roadblocks including coastal Cape residents who vocally oppose windmills messing up ... Complete story »

---

IllinoisOpinions
23 Oct 2006

Windmills will yield nothing but blight

At the "meeting'' with Invenergy representatives on Oct. 11 at the Interstate Center, we were told that the energy produced would be used locally. However, when really pressed, the rep conceded that there was a "possibility'' that it may go to Chicago. Now, three days later, I read in the Pantagraph that the power will be ... Complete story »

---

IllinoisNews
23 Oct 2006

Candidates shed light on energy proposals

Consider it the war of the energy plans. The three candidates for Illinois governor all have proposals that would harness the state's agricultural bounty to help fuel automobiles while developing the economy, though they differ on the scope of public assistance that should be offered. Democrat Rod Blagojevich, Republican Judy Baar Topinka and Green Party ... Complete story »

Turitea 19 Oct 2006

New ZealandNews
19 Oct 2006

Reserve wind farm gets the green light

The city has taken the first step toward having a wind farm in the Turitea Reserve. Last night, Palmerston North City Council's infrastructural well-being committee voted 12-3 to change the purpose of the reserve to allow renewable electricity generation. That recommendation now goes to the full council to be approved. Chairman Peter Claridge said he felt like he ... Complete story »

---

New ZealandNews
19 Oct 2006

Turitea wind farm debate something of a fizzer

People attending the council's wind farm debate last night were met at the door by a security guard. The council may have thought there was going to be a revolt, but the guard's services were not required. The infrastructural well-being committee meeting started at 5pm, but the debate didn't start until 8.30pm and lasted 90 minutes, so ... Complete story »

Turitea Wind Farm

New ZealandNews
18 Oct 2006

Turitea Reserve wind farm fight heats up for meeting

Legal threats hang over a city council committee meeting tonight that will decide if wind turbines should be allowed in the Turitea Reserve. If the infrastructural well-being committee backs putting turbines into the reserve, a protest group has threatened to take the council to the High Court to stop it. The group, the Friends of the Turitea ... Complete story »

WIND WATCH 17 OCT 2006

New ZealandNews
17 Oct 2006

Reserve to be protected

Mighty River Power will have to pay the city million if the quality of the water supply deteriorates during construction of a wind farm in the Turitea Reserve. And Mighty River Power will be required to have public liability insurance of million to cover potential risks to the water supply, a report to the ... Complete story »

---

New ZealandNews
17 Oct 2006

Mayor Tanguay urges public to attend wind farm debate

One of the most anticipated debates of the year will be held at the Convention Centre in Palmerston North tomorrow night. The first step toward a wind farm development in the Turitea Reserve will be discussed by the Palmerston North City Council's infrastructural well-being committee, which will make its recommendation on the propo- sal. Mayor Heather Tanguay ... Complete story »

New Zealand News 16 Oct 2006

Turitea friends unite to fight wind farm

Environmental concerns are at the forefront of a society formed to oppose the Turitea wind farm. Supporters met last night to prepare the battleground. An incorporated society has been formed to "put the council on notice" over the proposed Turitea wind farm. More than 60 people attended a meeting of the newly formed Friends of the Turitea ... Complete story »

Wind Action News (Harvey)

Hi All

In particular check out the article which includes plans for the community to get an annual grant and community fund with actual figures.

Harvey

< http://www.windaction.org/news/5600>Sheltered in every way but one- Massive wind project divides a British isle October 6, 2006 by Tom Hundley, Tribune Foreign Correspondent in Chicago Tribune

Subject: Industrial Wind Alert! 2006-10-09 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

News and Information from Industrial Wind Action Group <http://www.windaction.org/>www.windaction.org facts, analysis, exposure of wind energy's real impacts

Issue: 2006-10-09

(You are receiving this email because you subscribed at our web site. <http://www.windaction.org/subscribe>Click here to unsubscribe)

Announcement

CONFERENCE: Wildlife and Utility-Scale Wind Energy Development of the Central Appalachians

When: December 2, 2006 Where: Boehm Science Center (North Campus) at Kutztown University of Pennsylvania in Kutztown, PA What: Examine issues pertaining to the siting of utility-scale wind energy facilities in the Central Appalachian states of MD, PA, VA, and WV. Who: Speakers including D. Daniel Boone, William Evans, Thomas Kunz, Donald Heintzelman and a host of other prominent wildlife biologists, avian and bat experts, and environmental scientists.

For registration and more information, please visit http://www.kutztown.edu/acad/geography/wildlifeconf.htm or contact Donald S. Heintzelman at donsh@enter.net

<http://www.windaction.org/news>News Articles

<http://www.windaction.org/news/5642 >Wind farms may suffer in plan to boost other fuel sources October 9, 2006 by Angela Jameson in The Times THE Government is proposing to favour some renewable energy sources over others in an attempt to kick-start types of green power that have been slow to take off. The approach could mean that less well developed forms of renewable energy, such as marine or solar power, receive more subsidy in the form of Renewables Obligation Certificates (ROCs). Established forms of renewables, such as onshore wind farms, could receive fewer ROCs. The proposals to reform the ROC system were issued for consultation today as Alistair Darling, the Trade and Industry Secretary, stuck the first spade in the ground at what will be Britain's biggest onshore wind farm — Whitelee — operated by ScottishPower on Eaglesham Moor outside Glasgow. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5642>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General|
< http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK

<http://www.windaction.org/news/5629>Continental Divide October 9, 2006 by David Adams in Forbes But while the problems faced on either side of the Atlantic are much the same, America and Europe have taken different paths toward finding solutions. Neither side can claim victory. Despite a host of initiatives, new technologies and regulations, alternative energy remains a patchwork affair that has done little to offset needs. Increasingly, both sides are looking to the other to see what can be learned. The guiding principal in Europe has been government mandates. European Union member states are led by ambitious long-term targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Rules also require they develop increased energy capacity from renewable sources. By comparison, Washington, D. C. still prefers to let technology be the driving force in the quest for low cost alternatives to fossil fuels. While some tax incentives do exist (for ethanol and wind energy), there are no federal energy mandates besides a meager Renewable Fuel Standard passed last year by Congress to boost production of ethanol and biodiesel. Mostly it's left up to the individual states. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5629>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c58/>Europe| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c61/>USA| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General

<http://www.windaction.org/news/5628>Can planting trees really give you a clear carbon conscience? October 7, 2006 by David Adam, environment correspondent in Guardian Unlimited Carbon offset schemes are designed to neutralise the effects of the carbon dioxide our activities produce by investing in projects that cut emissions elsewhere. They work through the rapidly growing trade in carbon credits, each worth the equivalent of a tonne of carbon. Offset companies typically buy carbon credits from projects that plant trees or encourage a switch from fossil fuels to renewable energy. They sell credits to individuals and companies who want to go "carbon neutral". Some climate experts say offsets are dangerous because they dissuade people from changing their behaviour. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5628>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c56/>Asia| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c57/>Australia / New Zealand| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c58/>Europe| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c59/>North America (non-USA)| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c61/ >USA| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5637>Power plants generate debate October 7, 2006 by R. A. DYER in STAR-TELEGRAM On an April afternoon in Dallas, not long after parts of the state had lost power in a series of rolling blackouts, Gov. Rick Perry made a get-tough proclamation. "We're not going to let the bureaucrats jerk us around," he said. The governor was talking about electricity that day — specifically 11 coal-fired plants proposed by TXU — and the bureaucrats he challenged weren't those in Washington but the ones in the state government. Perry stood shoulder-to-shoulder with John Wilder, TXU's CEO, when he made the pronouncement. The "bureaucrats won't be allowed to hold up approval" for the TXU plants, Perry said. His support of those plants has become a hot issue in his race for re-election. Perry called last year's blackouts a "wake-up" call for a state that needs more energy, but his major rivals say the state can find a more environmentally friendly way to meet that challenge. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5637>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c104/>Texas| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


 < http://www.windaction.org/news/5625>You feel better, but is your carbon offset just hot air? October 7, 2006 by David Adam, environment correspondent in Guardian Unlimited Green consumers and businesses who want to neutralise their carbon emissions face being ripped off by unscrupulous operators who exploit the growing market in carbon offset schemes, a Guardian investigation has revealed. The surge in interest in such schemes, which invest millions of pounds in forestry and clean energy projects in the developing world, has created a lucrative market in carbon, which is unregulated and subject to little scrutiny. Campaigners and analysts say independent standards are urgently needed to protect consumers and to ensure the promised carbon savings are delivered. Francis Sullivan, a carbon offset expert who led attempts by banking group HSBC to neutralise its emissions, said: "There will be individuals and companies out there who think they're doing the right thing but they're not. I am sure that people are buying offsets in this unregulated market that are not credible. I am sure there are people buying nothing more than hot air." < http://www.windaction.org/news/5625>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c56/>Asia| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c57/>Australia / New Zealand| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c58/>Europe| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c59/>North America (non-USA)| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c61/ >USA| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


 <http://www.windaction.org/news/5624>Appeal of CWLP permit rejected October 7, 2006 by Chris Wetterich, Staff Writer in Journal Register The focus will shift back to the Springfield City Council in the city's power plant saga following Friday's dismissal by the U. S. Environmental Appeals Board of developer David Maulding's appeal of City Water, Light and Power's permit to build a new generator. Aldermen on the utilities committee will consider three ordinances Wednesday that would essentially re-enact the original deal the city made with the Sierra Club to forego its objections to the permit and make CWLP more environmentally friendly. The difference is that the ordinances call for no binding contract with the Sierra Club. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5624>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c75/>Illinois| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning


< http://www.windaction.org/news/5610>Fight picking up on renewable energy ballot measure October 7, 2006 by Rachel La Corte, Associated Press in kgw.com In a state where environmental issues often find ample support, an initiative to compel utilities to use cleaner energy should be the least controversial of the three measures on the statewide ballot in November. But after months of little to no debate over the measure — which would require the state's large utilities to increase renewable energy sources to 15 percent of their supply by 2020 — opponents have started speaking out, arguing that Initiative 937 would raise customers' rates. "It's a feel-good initiative," said Chris McCabe, spokesman for the Association of Washington Business, which is opposed to the measure. "Everyone wants a cleaner environment. It's easy for people to buy into that. It's one of those things where the devil is in the details." < http://www.windaction.org/news/5610>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c108/>Washington| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5605>Kyoto linked to soaring power bills October 6, 2006 by Bill Curry in The Globe and Mail Canadians would see their hydro and natural-gas bills spike dramatically should the three opposition parties succeed in forcing the government to comply with Kyoto, Environment Minister Rona Ambrose warned Thursday. Ms. Ambrose was appearing before the Commons environment committee for the first time since she was sworn in to Prime Minister Stephen Harper's cabinet in February. Though she outlined the broad direction of her fall environmental plan and gave a few more hints as to where the government is headed, opposition MPs left frustrated that she did not provide any new information. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5605>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c59/>North America (non-USA)| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5600>Sheltered in every way but one- Massive wind project divides a British isle October 6, 2006 by Tom Hundley, Tribune Foreign Correspondent in Chicago Tribune And now we are facing this terrible thing that threatens the very essence of what Lewis is. It's a small island. It's unique. And this will tear it asunder, " he said. The "terrible thing" to which he refers is a plan to construct what some promote as an environmental and economic blessing--a vast wind farm. Two British energy conglomerates have applied for permission to build 234 giant wind turbines that would generate 702 megawatts of power, one of the largest such projects in Europe. The turbines would be 460 feet high; their rotors would have a diameter of 330 feet. A Boeing 747 jumbo jet could fly through the circumference with room to spare. "There'd be no escaping them, " said Catriona Campbell, whose kitchen window view would be compromised by dozens of the turbines about a mile away. She calls them a "physical and cultural desecration. " "This is the land of our ancestors. If we lose it, we've lost the thing that makes us who we are, " she said. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5600>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning


< http://www.windaction.org/news/5616>Conference to focus on mountain issues October 6, 2006 by Betty Jespersen, Staff Writer in Central Maine Morning Sentinel RANGELEY -- From wind power to housing developments, bio-diversity to acid rain, conservation to jobs -- the pressures on Maine's mountains are increasing and policy makers, the business community and the public need to be remember the environmental needs of the mountains themselves, say organizers of a major upcoming conference. The Maine Mountain Conference on Saturday, Oct. 21, is being held at Saddleback Mountain resort's new base lodge with its dramatic vistas of the western mountains. Organizers expect more than 200 people to attend to hear speakers, scientists, historians, planners, residents and outdoor advocates talk about the significance and the future of the mountains. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5616>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c82/>Maine| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning


< http://www.windaction.org/news/5577>Six-month program to monitor Altamont Pass bird deaths OK'd October 6, 2006 by Chris Metinko, Contra Costa Times in The Mercury News Alameda County supervisors approved the initial phase of a monitoring system that will study the impact the Altamont windmills have on scores of birds — including golden eagles, red tail hawks, burrowing owls and other protected species. The board unanimously approved the $610, 000, six-month program after hesitating in July to support a $3 million, three-year plan to monitor bird deaths in the Altamont. At that July meeting, supervisors agreed to cap the program — to be paid for by the turbine operators in the Altamont — at $2 million, saying costs for the monitoring had spiraled out of control. The monitoring program will be a collaborative operation of UC Santa Cruz, WEST Inc. and Jones & Stokes, the top three bidders for the project. The group will monitor avian deaths at the 5, 400 windmills east of Livermore. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5577>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c36/>Impact on Birds| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c38/>Impact on Wildlife| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c66/>California| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General

<http://www.windaction.org/news/5575>W. Va. Supreme Court to hear Grant County wind farm case October 6, 2006 in The Charleston Gazette The state Supreme Court has unanimously agreed to consider a case involving the development of a 200-turbine wind farm near Mount Storm. The five justices voted Wednesday to consider residents' appeal of a Grant County Circuit Court ruling that dismissed their attempt to halt construction of the $300 million project. Residents say the project would be a nuisance and would ruin property values. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5575>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c110/>West Virginia| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5557>Energy chiefs ditch wind-farm plan to safeguard golden eagles October 5, 2006 by John Ross in The Scotsman A wind-farm proposal has been abandoned because the area where it was to be built is used by golden eagles and red kites. Perth-based Scottish and Southern Energy (SSE) has confirmed it will not proceed with its proposal to build 20 turbines at Glen Tarken, near Comrie. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5557>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c36/>Impact on Birds| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c38/>Impact on Wildlife| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5552>MNR denies lake use for wind turbines; Decision cancels public meeting October 4, 2006 in Leamington Post A proposed project for wind turbines in Lake Erie off the shores of Leamington and Kingsville will not go ahead. Kingsville Mayor Nelson Santos was pleased by the decision made by the Minister of Natural Resources and said Wednesday night's public meeting at Migration Hall has been canceled as a result. "For us, this is the appropriate decision," said Santos following the announcement by MPPs Bruce Crozier and Pat Hoy Tuesday morning that the MNR will not allow the use of Crown lands in the bed of Lake Erie for the proposed project. "It's a positive move, representing the wishes of the town of Kingsville and its residents," he added. While Santos said they still support the use of green energy, he said they must find a more appropriate location. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5552>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c59/>North America (non-USA)| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5525>'Wind rush' set to end, says minister in call for shift in emphasis towards alternative types of renewable energy October 3, 2006 in The Scotsman Scotland's "wind rush" - the massive surge in applications to build windfarms - may be coming to an end, the environment minister signalled yesterday. Ross Finnie, who attended the launch of the Scottish Environment Protection Agency's report, said the emphasis should now be on other forms of renewable energy such as tidal, wave and biomass. According to a report earlier this year by environmental groups, windfarms made up nearly 90 per cent of renewable energy schemes planned or under construction. If this rate of development were to continue, nearly 600 square kilometres - an area bigger than North Lanarkshire - would be covered by windfarms in order to meet the 40 per cent renewable energy target for electricity by 2020. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5525>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5524>County Men Honored As Conservationists October 3, 2006 by Manley J. Anderson in The Post-Journal Two Chautauqua County residents are the first dual recipients of the Nature Sanctuary Society of Western New York's ''Conservationist of the Year Award.'' The presentation to Leonard DeFrancisco of Falconer and Gil Randell of Mayville was made at the society's annual banquet in recognition of their work in preventing construction of a wind energy project across a major North American bird migration route. The two men are principals in the Ripley Hawk Watch project that has gathered considerable information for more than 20 years regarding the northward migration of birds, bats and some insect species along the ridges bordering the Lake Erie shore. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5524>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c36/>Impact on Birds| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c38/>Impact on Wildlife| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c95/>New York| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/news/5526>Texas, private partners to invest $10B in wind energy October 2, 2006 in Dallas Business Journal The state of Texas will partner with private-sector parties to invest more than $10 billion in new wind energy infrastructure, Gov. Rick Perry said Monday. The wind energy initiative will diversify the state's energy production, clean up the air and help Texas surpass its renewable energy goals, Perry said in an announcement Monday at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5526>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c104/>Texas| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General

< http://www.windaction.org/opinions>Opinions

<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5618>Care has to be taken when placing windmills across state October 8, 2006 in The Patriot-News Like everything else, common sense and a decent respect for the other important elements in the equation must be part of windmill siting. While we understand that owners of windmills are looking for optimal wind conditions, if this energy source is to succeed on any scale it is going to have to apply more sophisticated approaches to deploy them under less than ideal but workable conditions, such as in urban settings and industrial parks. Unless the state adopts windmill-siting standards, it can only mean trouble for an alternative form of energy the Rendell administration is heavily promoting. That is not an approach that can make serious headway in moving the state away from its overreliance on fossil fuels. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5618>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c99/>Pennsylvania| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c122/>Zoning/Planning


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5604>Bracks diverts power from the people October 6, 2006 in The Australian MISSING from the deluge of more than 300 reports tabled in this last week of parliament before the state election were two key documents the Bracks Government has chosen to keep secret. Both would shed important new light on big government election initiatives and allow voters to make a clearer assessment of them, but it appears that for political reasons they will be kept under wraps. The first report concerns the economic impact of the Government's wind farms policy and calculates the effect on the average power bill..... Premier Steve Bracks and his ministers claim the increase will be just $10 on the average annual power bill, but they refuse to release the research that underpins this claim. The Opposition claims the increase will be more like $80 a year, but without seeing the research both figures are effectively just unsupported claims of politicians. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5604>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c52/>Energy Policy| <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c57/>Australia / New Zealand| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5587>Planning Process Ignores Public Opposition October 6, 2006 in Times & Star Wind power is becoming one of the most scandalous planning issues of our time, guided in England, Wales and Scotland by advice documents which presume in favour of the industry almost irrespective of public feeling. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5587>more...


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5573>Let the Market Decide October 5, 2006 in Energy Biz Magazine The global warming problem is serious enough that we should set politics aside and attack the problem in the most effective, economic manner. We should simply require that CO2 emissions be reduced (or apply a financial disincentive) and then get out of the way and let the market decide on the best approach. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5573>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c61/>USA| <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5558>The 'green' energy credits that aren't October 5, 2006 in Seattle Post-Intelligencer In the 16th- century church, those who were long on cash but short on righteous living could balance the equation by buying indulgences, representing a sort of absolution for sinful behavior. Indulgences may have disappeared about the time of Martin Luther, but they seem to be alive and thriving in a more contemporary religion — the Church of the Green. Wells Fargo & Co. announced this week that it is buying renewable energy certificates for 550 million kilowatt-hours of wind energy a year for three years. The bank said the acquisition makes it the "largest corporate purchaser of renewable energy in the United States," but it's hardly the first. Everyone from the National Farmers Union to Audubon New York to Whole Foods to Starbucks to FedEx Kinko's has done similar deals. And how much of this "clean" wind-generated electricity will Wells Fargo be taking for its own branches, offices and facilities, to supplant supposedly "dirty" power it's getting from other sources? Not a single watt. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5558>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c47/>Tax Breaks & Subsidies| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c61/>USA| <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c108/>Washington| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5598>Energy Choices for Hawaii October 4, 2006 in Hawaii Reporter Both senatorial candidates as did many other candidates used the same talking points for Hawaii's energy future. Many uniformly supported and promoted wind, solar, and ethanol, as the road to energy nirvana. The politics of Hawaii demands an absolute deference to these energy sources or risk political oblivion. But it needs to be said that a state or nation heavily dependent upon these future energy sources is in serious trouble. Yet this is where the political forces of Hawaii are leading. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5598>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c35/>Technology| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c72/>Hawaii| <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c122/>Zoning/Planning


<http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5550 >"Hot & Cold Media Spin: A Challenge To Journalists Who Cover Global Warming" September 25, 2006 I firmly believe that when the history of our era is written, future generations will look back with puzzlement and wonder why we spent so much time and effort on global warming fears and pointless solutions like the Kyoto Protocol. Editor's Note: The pdf version with charts is available via the link below. < http://www.windaction.org/opinions/5550>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/opinions/c112/>General

<http://www.windaction.org/pictures>Pictures


* <http://www.windaction.org/pictures/5634>Blacklaw in South Lanarkshire < http://www.windaction.org/pictures/5634>see...
* Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/pictures/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/pictures/c120/>UK
* <http://www.windaction.org/pictures/5266>Wind Turbines < http://www.windaction.org/pictures/5266>see...
* Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/pictures/c112/>General

Invitation: Marilynn Webb: Mahinerangi (sticky)

Dear friends of ULP,

you are warmly invited to attend the opening of Marilynn Webb's exhibition, Mahinerangi, at 6 pm, Monday 16 October, in the Salisbury House Gallery (104 Bond st, Dunedin). The exhibition will be launched by the director of the Eastern Southland Gallery, Jim Geddes, and run from 16 October to 20 October. Viewing times are 10 am to 4 pm.

Marilynn Webb ONZM, New Zealand's major living woman artist, has painted the Mahinerangi region for over thirty years. This exhibition is at once retrospective and purposive: a portion of the proceeds of a sale of Mahinerangi prints from this exhibition will help fund the society's campaign against the TrustPower and Meridian wind factories. The exhibition will also showcase a selection of recent designs incorporating work by poet Cilla McQueen, in honour of whom a plaque is to be laid in the Octagon this Friday as part of the Otago Festival of the Arts.

The link below shows a selection of the work to be exhibited:

http://www.salisburyhousegallery.com/webb/webb1.htm

We look forward to seeing you there,


ULP executive committee.

Govt takes wind farm reins

6 October 2006 By NICOLA LOBBAN, and JULIET LARKIN

The Government appears to be gearing up to push its view on national energy issues through a combined submission on what could become New Zealand's largest wind farm.

The Southland Times understands interested government departments have been told they are not to submit independently on Meridian Energy's controversial proposal to build a 176-turbine wind farm on the Lammermoor Ranges in Central Otago.

Department of Conservation Otago planner Bruce Hill said yesterday that while no final decision had been made, Cabinet would ultimately decide whether to make an "all-government" submission on Project Hayes.

If it went ahead, the submission would be co-ordinated by the Environment Ministry, he said.

Central Otago Mayor Malcolm Macpherson said several "indications" pointed to an all-government submission being on the cards.

In the absence of a national energy policy it was likely the Government could decide to represent the interests of several departments in a combined submission in recognition of the national significance of the proposed wind farm.

The proposal was notified by the Central Otago District Council yesterday after it was first lodged by Meridian Energy in July.

Consultation, which started in May, has divided many Central Otago groups because of concerns about potential visual and aural pollution and other environmental effects on the proposed site.

Mr Macpherson said he believed the desire to "keep the decks clear" so the Government could submit on the proposal without conflict of interest underlaid Environment Minister David Benson-Pope's decision not to "call-in" the proposal when he was requested to by an action group in July.

With more than one Government minister signalling the need for independent renewable energy sources in future, a major wind energy project was likely to be something the Government would take an interest in, he said. "I'm putting my bet on a combined whole of government submission in the absence of an energy policy."

A spokeswoman for Energy Minister David Parker said a decision had not been made and it was unlikely the minister was ready to comment on the issue.

SCOOP

Turbines creating ill wind

New ZealandNews 06 Oct 2006

Turbines creating ill wind

Councillor Peter Claridge's infrastructural well-being committee will decide whether the Turitea Reserve Management plan should be changed to allow a wind farm on October 18. Its recommendation goes to the full council but these are nearly always accepted, he said. Cr Claridge says the real arguments that people are most interested in, such as how many wind ... Complete story »

Reminder: Meeting Tomorrow 3 October

Dear all,

first off, ULP fortnightly meeting tomorrow (Tuesday 3 October, 5.15).
This will be held in the printmaking room of Otago Arts School,
off Albany st. All are welcome to attend.

secondly, Geraldine Tait has asked for her comments below concerning
written submissions for the proposed DCC plan changes to be circulated.
THIS IS IMPORTANT, and not just for wind farms. It's an opportunity to
tell the DCC firmly what you want!!!! (all members should have this in their email)

Thirdly, included below is Harvey Jones' latest info from
www.windaction.org. His overview of the included info is:

A few points of interest in this news digest. Check out the item about the windfarm refused in
the UK as there are already too many wind farms there.Followed by the Item on the Turitea windfarm in the Manawatu. Some great picture links to the earthworks at the new Tararua II windfarms which others have requested as well.  Now freely available to use.(See Harvey's own post "News Updates (Wind Action) below)


AND OF COURSE, TrustPower, as most will know, have decided to cut the DCC out of their lodgement for the first two stages of the Mahinerangi Wind Farm. They intend to reapply first with the Clutha District Council and Otago Regional Council, and then lodge in two to five years
with the DCC for their third stage, on the contested tussockland. I personally doubt that the cumulative impact can be contained within the Clutha District Council, and wish to remind all of the requisite infrastructural exigencies (power transmission, roading, traffic, run-off) which will still be an issue.TrustPower will lodge with ORC and CDC  in approximately six weeks.

Hope all are well,

R

Nwes Updates (Wind Action)

Hi All

 A few points of interest in this news digest. Check out the item about the windfarm refused in the UK as there are already too many wind farms there. Followed by the Item on the Turitea windfarm in the Manawatu.

Some great picture links to the earthworks at the new Tararua II windfarms which others have requested as well. Now freely available to use. As usual more info in the news by location for NZ at
http://www.windaction.org/news/c57/ Includes the latest news about problems with warranty fixes for Te Apiti

Harvey


**************************************************

News and Information from Industrial Wind Action Group <http://www.windaction.org/> www.windaction.org facts, analysis, exposure of wind energy's real impacts

Issue: 2006-09-25


<http://www.windaction.org/news>News Articles

< http://www.windaction.org/news/5339>Bovina Overwhelmingly Rejects Industrial Scale Wind Turbines September 25, 2006 by Alliance for Bovina press release in IWA These are the results of a poll undertaken by the Alliance for Bovina on wind turbines. The poll, consisting of the following two questions, was mailed on September 1, 2006 to all taxpayers and registered voters in Bovina, with the following results tabulated by September 21, 2006: < http://www.windaction.org/news/5339>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c95/>New York| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5329 >State Wildlife Agency Advises the State Corporation Commission that the Proposed Highland Wind Project Presents Unacceptable Risk to Wildlife September 25, 2006 by Virginia Wind Press Release The September 20, 2006 VDGIF letter states: "We support the use of alternative energy sources, including wind energy. However, based on review of the information provided thus far by the Highland project applicant, in the absence of accountable mitigation conditions . .. we feel this project presents an unacceptable risk to wildlife." < http://www.windaction.org/news/5329>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c36/>Impact on Birds| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c37/>Impact on Bats| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c38/>Impact on Wildlife| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c106/>Virginia| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5302>Power Proposal May Prove National Model September 23, 2006 by William McCall, Associated Press in Hartford Current PORTLAND, Ore. -- At the halfway point between the West Coast energy crisis of 2001 and the next major electricity contract renewal year of 2011, a federal power marketing agency is proposing a policy change that could affect rates in the Pacific Northwest for generations and become a national model for energy development. Northwest hydropower is one of the cheapest energy resources in the nation - about half the current market rate for electricity. The Bonneville Power Administration - which sells power in all of Washington, Oregon and Idaho and parts of California, Nevada, Utah, Wyoming and Montana - announced this summer that it wants to change the way it charges utilities for its wholesale power to keep rates low. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5302>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c87/>Montana| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General < http://www.windaction.org/news/5287>Jury's out on controversial wind farm September 23, 2006 by Mike Johnston in Daily Record After sitting through more than 27 hours of hearings this week, listening to or reading testimony from 35 witnesses and cross examining some of those labeled as expert witnesses, the jury is finally out on the controversial Kittitas Valley Wind Power Project. The "jury" - the 7-member state Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council - may decide by late December what to recommend to Gov. Chris Gregoire on the 65-turbine wind farm proposed for 12 miles northwest of Ellensburg. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5287>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c108/>Washington| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning < http://www.windaction.org/news/5286>Wind farm reviewers: Comment period over September 22, 2006 by Mark Harrington, Staff Writer in Newsday Despite criticism that its computer system for taking comments about the proposed Long Island wind farm was flawed, the federal agency overseeing the environmental review of the project said yesterday it won't reopen the public comment period. Residents, legislators and environmentalists had called on the Minerals Management Service to review the computer system, which agency officials acknowledged had flaws. The federal agency will use comments it receives to formulate guidelines for an environmental impact review of the wind farm. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5286>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c95/>New York| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5284 >CV ordinance may kill wind turbine plan September 22, 2006 by Jim Austin, Editor in Cooperstown Crier CHERRY VALLEY- Town supervisor Tom Garretson made it clear to Reunion Power that his first concern is the residents of Cherry Valley and not Reunion Power's ability to put a wind farm on East Hill. During Thursday night's meeting in which the town board unanimously agreed to schedule a public hearing on a proposed wind ordinance, Garrestton said they needed a law ``thats going to protect the town. That comes first.'' He went on to say that if one developer finds they can not work within the confines of the town's proposed wind ordinance then perhaps another developer can. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5284>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c95/>New York| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5275 >Koch's New Fight September 22, 2006 by Tim Doyle in Forbes On a blustery, gray morning in August, William I. Koch, the billionaire energy mogul, gazes out a window in his Osterville, Mass., home down to the choppy waters of Nantucket Sound, just a few hundred yards past a barrier island of sand that protects the seven boats parked at his dock. "I go out and sail on the Sound; it's so beautiful," says the 1992 America's Cup champ. "Why would you want to sail in a forest of windmills?" < http://www.windaction.org/news/5275>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c80/>Massachusetts| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General <http://www.windaction.org/news/5273>After 381 complaints windfarm is refused September 22, 2006 by Sion Morgan in Lampeter Today A CONTROVERSIAL proposal for a windfarm to be built near Talgarreg has collapsed after Ceredigion planners rejected the application after nearly three hours of heated debate. The development would have seen 10 wind turbines standing 100 metres high at Rhosygarn but members of the county council's develop-ment committee rejected the scheme because they felt there were too many windfarms in Ceredigion. They decided to refuse the application despite officers raising no objections and claims by the developers and landowners involved that it would benefit the local community. Cllr Fred Williams said: "We have all done our bit for renewable energy and I think we must come to a stop. "We have done enough for wind energy in Ceredigion I wonder if the government would accept wind turbines on the white cliffs of Dover." < http://www.windaction.org/news/5273>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5267 >Turitea wind farm threat to city September 22, 2006 by Helen Harvey in Manawatu Standard A wind farm in the Turitea Reserve could ruin the city water supply. Erosion could be a problem that would be difficult to overcome, a Massey University geography professor says. The $1 million a year the Palmerston North City Council is hoping to get for its wind farm might not be enough to pay for the damage it does, John Flenley says. The problem is the removal of vegetation – native bush or scrub, whatever – to install the turbines themselves, as well as the road construction needed to the site. And it could take 100 years for all that vegetation to grow back. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5267>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c40/>Erosion| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c57/>Australia / New Zealand| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c116/>Impact on Landscape <http://www.windaction.org/news/5265>Call for tough line on wind farms September 22, 2006 in BBC News A petition is calling on the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) to push for wind farm developments to be suspended in the UK. Internet lobby group Proact, which co-ordinates wildlife campaigns, said it has collected 3, 248 signatures. Proact's David Conlin said the society does not go "far enough" in opposing wind developments. The RSPB said it will respond to the petition, but added that it deals with farm proposals on a case by case basis. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5265>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c36/>Impact on Birds| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c38/>Impact on Wildlife| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK <http://www.windaction.org/news/5261>The Ramblers Association has vowed to fight planning applications for windfarms September 21, 2006 by Anna Burdett in News and Star RAMBLERS across Cumbria are to join forces in the fight against wind turbines as part of a national campaign to stop their march across the countryside. The move is in direct contrast to calls from other groups such as Greenpeace, who support windfarm developments. Mike Murgatroyd, secretary of the west Cumbria group of the Ramblers Association, said: "Ramblers, in common with a lot of other groups, appreciate the countryside and don't want to see it despoiled. "I think they are a blight on the landscape, wherever they are." < http://www.windaction.org/news/5261>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c116/>Impact on Landscape| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c120/>UK| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5256 >National Grid: New Transmission Policies Are Needed to Realize Renewable Generation's Potential in the U. S. September 21, 2006 by National Grid Press Release in Yahoo News WESTBOROUGH, Mass. — (BUSINESS WIRE) — Sept. 21, 2006 — In a white paper published today, National Grid urged federal and state policymakers to address current inadequacies in U. S. transmission policies that create obstacles for wind and other renewable generators in accessing the country's electric grid. In the paper, entitled "Transmission and Wind Energy: Capturing the Prevailing Winds for the Benefit of Customers," National Grid advocates for the development of a consistent and appropriate policy approach to support the transmission investment needed to harness wind power and integrate it into the U. S. electricity grid while continuing to maintain system reliability, and deliver its full benefits to electricity market users and customers. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5256>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c52/>Energy Policy| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c61/>USA| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5247>Kittitas wind power project meets resistance September 21, 2006 by Gary Chittim in KING 5 News The site in Kittitas County has all the attributes the Whisky Dick Mountain site has – a steady supply of wind and nearby high power transmission lines. But it also has something the Whiskey Dick site doesn't have – a loud group of opponents. "It's location. Wild Horse Project was never affected because there wasn't many people around," said Sandy Sandall, a neighbor who opposed the project. Sandy Sandall and his neighbors worry the project would block their panoramic valley views and lower property values. But the owners of the land where the farm would be built are all for it. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5247>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c108/>Washington| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning < http://www.windaction.org/news/5244>Hundreds pack chambers to oppose wind turbines; Council turns down project September 21, 2006 in Leamington Post Nearly 300 people attended a Leamington Council meeting Monday night to oppose a wind farm project for Lake Erie, that would see 59 wind turbines just east of Leamington marina. The total project proposes 119 wind turbines in Pigeon Bay, including locations just off Kingsville and Union. After hearing a presentation made by Kingsville's Dr. John Lee, who is against the proposal, and a representative, Bill Climie, of Southpoint Wind Power, council unanimously voted against it. They then made several motions to send letters to different ministries, including the Ministry of Natural Resources, Oceans and Fisheries, Parks Canada, and local MPs and MPPs to ensure that all assessments and environmental concerns would be addressed prior to the installation of any wind turbine in the Lake. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5244>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c59/>North America (non-USA)| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning < http://www.windaction.org/news/5240>Objectors to giant wind farm win landmark planning battle September 21, 2006 by Treacy Hogan in unison.ie Wind farm objectors, including a number of large-scale barley tillage farmers, yesterday won a landmark planning battle, shooting down plans for 17 giant wind turbines, taller than the Spire of Dublin. After a high-profile fight, An Bord Pleanala finally refused permission for Dutch developers WEOM to erect the 400ft-high turbines at Kilbraney, Co Wexford. The decision puts down a national marker that planners will not automatically give the green light for wind farms where they can visually damage the landscape and impact on the lives of local people. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5240>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c45/>Impact on People| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c58/>Europe| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c116/>Impact on Landscape| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning < http://www.windaction.org/news/5202>Invenergy Wind to reassess $250 million project September 19, 2006 by Brian Paynter, Staff Reporter in Beaver Dam Daily Citizen BROWNSVILLE - Invenergy Wind LLC will re-evaluate its entire $250 million project after the Federal Aviation Administration recently issued hazard determination permits for 80 of its 133 turbine sites, according to Neil Palmer, public affairs consultant for the Chicago-based developer. He said Invenergy Wind plans to obtain pricing updates on turbines, equipment and construction as well as establish a schedule after nearly a year-long delay while the Department of Defense studied the effect wind turbines would have on military radar. "Once we get through that we'll have a better definition of when we'll start building but we don't know that today, " Palmer said. He said the DOD, which doesn't have the authority to issue permits for wind turbines, asked the FAA to grant them until the DOD concludes its study. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5202>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c51/>Safety| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c109/>Wisconsin| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General <http://www.windaction.org/news/5182 >Yarmouth to revisit wind power bylaw September 18, 2006 by Patrick Cassidy in Cape Cod Times Committee members worked with the planning board and looked at bylaws in Fairhaven, Harwich and Orleans. They were also wary of possible disputes like the one in Sandwich over residential wind turbines and ''wanted to be more restrictive rather than opening the floodgates, '' Braginton-Smith said. Sections of the bylaw addressed height restrictions, setbacks and noise generated by the turbines. It also addressed flicker, the visual effect of the moving turbine blades on the light from the sun. Despite a nod toward the hard work of the energy committee, Snowden moved to indefinitely postpone a vote on the bylaw article. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5182>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c80/>Massachusetts| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning < http://www.windaction.org/news/5180>MIT designs 'invisible, ' floating wind turbines September 18, 2006 by Nancy Stauffer in physorg.com An MIT researcher has a vision: Four hundred huge offshore wind turbines are providing onshore customers with enough electricity to power several hundred thousand homes, and nobody standing onshore can see them. The trick? The wind turbines are floating on platforms a hundred miles out to sea, where the winds are strong and steady. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5180>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c35/>Technology| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c61/>USA| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General <http://www.windaction.org/news/5249 >The Perry Town Board met Wednesday, September 13 to discuss possible changes to a local law regarding wind towers. September 14, 2006 in Warsaws County Courier The planning board had been working on a series of changes to a local law that would increase the distance a tower needs to be from an established residence from 1, 500 to 1, 750 feet. The town board and planning board were scheduled to go into executive session with the town attorney following the public meeting. Resident Valary Sahrle addressed the board, saying that an executive session was illegal. Many in the crowd stood to protest the executive session as Sahrle and Attorney Dadd discussed the matter. After much deliberation, Dadd suggested that no executive meeting be held that evening. "Let's not let this turn into a legal issue about an executive session, " he said. He informed the public and the board that "the existing procedure and process is more than adequate for the Town of Perry to ensure that a project that you don't want to happen will not happen. " He continued that if the town passed a moratorium or tried to change the local law mid-stream, they would open themselves to a lawsuit from Horizon. < http://www.windaction.org/news/5249>more... Filed under | <http://www.windaction.org/news/c95/>New York| < http://www.windaction.org/news/c112/>General| <http://www.windaction.org/news/c122/>Zoning/Planning <http://www.windaction.org/news/5338 >Wind goes out of green energy project's sails July 13, 2006 by Leo Lewis in The Times Online The p